Sound Engineering & Recording

792 members

PLUS
ValShal / Alfonso PeNa 1mo+2dy ago
Hi!! Can anyone give me your feedback on this?


   

11 people like this: soundman1955, BoneSaw, Mahzin, pramsay, WaiheDave, dogbizkits, TSTstudios, GELECTRIC, Moonrunner, Ulcur, GoYeah

Comments

Login to Comment
comment.user.userName PLUS

GoYeah   commented 1mo+2dy ago


Very nice ! Wondering if all seps are posted so a strong mix/master could be done ... Oh, just looked and, nope ... no seps ... Structurally speaking, the guitar solo is early in the song ... maybe placed before the 2:30 vocal break/transition ? Ending is a bit busy with backups ... trimming ? All in all it's a good song :)

comment.user.userName PLUS

ValShal   commented 1mo+2dy ago


Thanks for your comments!!! By the way, what does "backups" mean?

comment.user.userName PLUS

GoYeah   commented 1mo+2dy ago


Backup vocals ... the secondary voices behind .... behind the Lead voice

comment.user.userName PLUS

ValShal   commented 1mo+2dy ago


could you make it with the extends (sItems)?

comment.user.userName PLUS

GoYeah   commented 1mo+2dy ago


Indeed anyone could with the dry stems (dry means no effects whatsoever) just every track of instruments and vocals without reverb, delay or any fx ... I am sure several mixers would love doing this one, me first :)

comment.user.userName PLUS

GoYeah   commented 1mo+2dy ago


Simply upload all of them to your song's site and we will feast on a good song :)

comment.user.userName PLUS

GELECTRIC   commented 1mo+2dy ago


agree Luc

comment.user.userName PREMIER

kman   commented 1mo+2dy ago


Wonderful song, wonderful mix. I like it as it is. It has a nice low end that I like (u know I'm bass player :)). Overall very well balanced. I love the toms being fat but not at all exaggerated. I have no proposal to improve. Congratulations :))

comment.user.userName PLUS

ValShal   commented 1mo+2dy ago


It's nice to know that I'm going in the right direction. Jay has a lot to do with the low end, he has recorded and mixing the drums.

comment.user.userName PRO

tbase2000   commented 1mo+2dy ago


What a beautiful song. Well done! Here's feedback: Stereo panned hard left and right for acoustic rhythm. You can think of each part of the song being it's own scene which you need to produce a little differently than the others. That gives you momentum and creates fun opportunities. Late in the song there is a single strumming sad guitar with some vocals. That's cool but have him be saved along with the crecendio that brings you out of it into the chorus with some wide panned strumming guitars again. If you mix between wide panned and tight...you will get more emotion out of your mix. Just thoughts.

comment.user.userName PLUS

ValShal   commented 31 days ago


Tony your comments are always very accurate. I will try to do what you suggest. It's also possible that I have too many guitars right now. In the chorus I have two different acoustic guitar strumming open a little to the sides and an electric one also doing a strumming

comment.user.userName

Mahzin   commented 30 days ago


Great song. If you wish I can assist with mixing or mastering. Detail, the mix isn't bad and the master too, it's taste, but if you wish to see another different work ;).

comment.user.userName PLUS

ValShal   commented 29 days ago


Thanks, it's a good option!

comment.user.userName PLUS

soundman1955   commented 27 days ago


Yup, that's a hit. Congrats !

comment.user.userName PLUS

ValShal   commented 27 days ago


Thanks!!!

comment.user.userName

TSTstudios   commented 27 days ago


Lovely song! Sounds good :) Just a bit boxy sound on the vocal but that is in the recording and I would widen the harmony a little bit more But that is all about taste ;) Really a great song it is! Tom

comment.user.userName PLUS

ValShal   commented 27 days ago


I'm waiting for Jay. He recorded the drums but now he's not here and I need his tracks to finish the mix

comment.user.userName

TSTstudios   commented 27 days ago


If you have his mail it would be quicker then add a comment here I think